Is Tax Investigation Insurance Worth It? How to Decide
Share
It's the question behind every visit to this site, and the honest answer is that nobody can give it to you. Whether tax investigation insurance is worth it depends on your own perceived odds of an HMRC enquiry, what defending one would cost you, and how you feel about carrying that risk yourself. Those are your numbers, not ours.
What we can do is lay the question out properly. The decision has a shape, and once you can see it, most people find it answers itself one way or the other. We've put the case against as well as the case for, because a page that only argues one side isn't much help to anyone.
Start with what the insurance does
Tax investigation insurance, also called fee protection insurance, does one thing. If HMRC opens an enquiry into your tax affairs, it pays the professional fees for an accountant or tax adviser to deal with HMRC on your behalf, up to the policy limits.
It doesn't pay any tax HMRC decides you owe, or any interest or penalties. It doesn't make an enquiry less likely. It doesn't stop HMRC asking questions. It covers the cost of having someone qualified answer them for you.
That matters for the "worth it" question, because it tells you what you're weighing. You're not insuring against a tax bill. You're insuring against a professional fees bill that arrives whether or not HMRC finds anything wrong.
The three things that decide it
1. How likely is an enquiry?
Less likely than the scarier corners of the internet suggest, and more likely than "it'll never happen to me". HMRC opens hundreds of thousands of compliance checks a year across roughly twelve million Self Assessment returns and several million businesses. For a typical taxpayer with tidy records, the chance of a full enquiry in any single year is low. The chance of some kind of check over the lifetime of a business is a good deal higher.
Most checks aren't random. HMRC's systems compare your return against data from banks, the Land Registry, payroll, online platforms and overseas tax authorities, and a mismatch is what generates the letter. HMRC has been expanding this kind of data-led compliance work, and we've seen the effect in our own book: more claims in the past year than in any year before it. So the odds aren't the same for everyone. They tend to be higher if you:
- run a cash-heavy trade (construction, hospitality, taxis, hair and beauty);
- are a landlord, particularly with several properties or a recent sale;
- contract through your own limited company;
- have claimed R&D tax relief;
- have income from abroad, crypto assets or online platform sales;
- have filed late, amended returns more than once, or had an enquiry before.
None of those means you've done anything wrong. They mean your return has more places for a mismatch to appear.
2. What would an enquiry cost you without cover?
This is the number the premium should be measured against, and it's the one nobody mentions until the letter arrives.
An aspect enquiry, which looks at one item on your return, is the common kind. It typically runs three to six months and takes ten to fifteen hours of your accountant's time across several rounds of questions. At typical rates that's a bill of £1,500 to £3,000. A full enquiry into a whole return, sometimes several years of them, commonly runs nine to sixteen months and £5,000 to £10,000 in fees, more for complex cases.
Those fees are payable even when the enquiry closes with nothing owed. A large share of them do.
The useful exercise is to put your own figures in. Ask your accountant what they charge an hour and what they'd expect an enquiry into someone like you to involve. Most will tell you in a sentence.
3. How would you feel about paying that?
This is the part no table can answer. For some people, £2,500 appearing unexpectedly is an annoyance. For others it's a month's takings, or the difference between a good year and a bad one. For a lot of people the real cost isn't the money at all; it's the months of worry and the hours spent gathering paperwork while trying to run a business.
Insurance is a way of swapping an uncertain large cost for a certain small one. Whether that swap appeals depends on how much the uncertain cost would hurt. Only you know that.
The case against
A fair page has to make this properly, so here it is.
- In any one year, you'll probably not need it. Most policyholders never claim. If you're comfortable self-insuring and could absorb a few thousand pounds without strain, that is a perfectly rational position.
- The premium isn't tax deductible. HMRC treats fee protection premiums as not allowable, so there's no relief to soften the cost. We've set out why in our guide to whether tax investigation insurance is tax deductible.
- It has edges. Enquiries that have already started aren't covered. Nor are deliberate wrongdoing, tax avoidance schemes, the tax itself, or routine accounts work. Policies also carry conditions, such as returns having been filed on time. If your affairs are complicated in a way that might fall outside the cover, the policy is worth less to you than the headline suggests.
- You might already have it. Some accountants include fee protection in their annual fee, and some trade bodies include it in membership. It's worth checking before you buy twice.
- Hourly rates and limits vary. A cheap policy that pays £100 an hour when your accountant charges £200 leaves you funding half the bill. If you do decide to buy, our buyer's checklist sets out what to compare.
The case for
- The sums are lopsided. A sole trader's premium is roughly the cost of one hour of their accountant's time. A single aspect enquiry costs ten to fifteen of those hours. You don't need a high probability of an enquiry for the expected cost of going without to exceed the premium; you need a modest one.
- Enquiries don't wait for a convenient year. They tend to arrive when something has changed: a property sale, a new company, a big R&D claim, a jump in income. Those are often the years when money is already committed elsewhere.
- Good representation changes outcomes. An accountant who answers HMRC's questions precisely, and pushes back where HMRC has got it wrong, tends to close enquiries faster and with less tax at stake. When the fees are covered, there's no temptation to cut corners to keep the bill down.
- It removes a decision at a bad moment. With cover, the day the letter arrives you ring your accountant. Without it, you first have to decide how much defending yourself is worth.
Who tends to find it worth having
We can't tell you which group you're in, but from the people who buy from us, cover tends to be most valued by:
- Limited companies and contractors, where enquiries involve more records, more hours and more taxes at once, and where IR35 status can be in question.
- Landlords with more than one property, particularly after a sale, when HMRC's property data is most likely to throw up a query.
- Cash trades, where HMRC's risk models pay closer attention and record-keeping questions are common.
- Anyone who has claimed R&D relief, an area HMRC has been checking closely.
- People who simply don't want the worry, which is a legitimate reason and probably the most common one we hear.
At the other end, someone with a single PAYE income, no other sources and a straightforward return has fewer places for a mismatch to arise and the least to gain. Even then, the private individual policy exists because enquiries into rental or investment income do happen, and they're not always small.
A way to decide in five minutes
- Ask your accountant their hourly rate and what an enquiry into your affairs would typically take. Multiply the two.
- Look at the list of risk factors above and count how many apply to you.
- Ask yourself whether paying the figure from step 1 next year, unplanned, would be an annoyance or a problem.
- Check whether you already have cover through your accountant or a membership.
- If you'd buy, compare policies on the fee limit, hourly rate, excess and what's covered, not on the premium alone.
If step 3 comes out as "a problem" and step 2 is more than zero, most people stop there. If step 3 is "an annoyance" and step 2 is zero, many people decide to carry the risk themselves. Both are reasonable answers, and your accountant is a good person to talk it through with.
Quick questions
Does having insurance make an enquiry more likely?
No. Policy details are held by the insurer for the purpose of providing the cover and go no further. HMRC has no access to them, and having cover has no bearing on whether you're selected for a check.
Is it worth it if my affairs are simple?
The odds are lower and the enquiry, if it came, would probably be shorter. The premium is lower too. It comes down to step 3 above.
Can I just buy it when HMRC writes to me?
No. Cover has to be in place before HMRC gets in touch; an enquiry that has already started isn't covered by a policy bought afterwards. It's the same principle as any insurance.
What does it cost?
Every price is on one page in our guide to how much tax investigation insurance costs, and the FAQ covers how the cover works in detail.
Where that leaves you
Worth it is a judgement about your own odds, your own costs and your own appetite for risk. We've tried to give you the pieces rather than the answer. If you decide cover makes sense, our quote and buy page shows the price for your circumstances straight away. If you decide it doesn't, we hope the page has at least made the decision an informed one.
FeeProtect.com is arranged by Straight Solutions Ltd, an independent insurance intermediary authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA 315448). The insurance is underwritten by ARAG Legal Expenses Insurance Company Limited and administered by ARAG plc. Cover is subject to the policy terms and conditions. Figures for enquiry durations and typical professional fees are illustrative, based on published industry experience, and will vary by case. This guide is general information to help you weigh up the cover. It is not advice on whether it is suitable for you.